4 January

Flower Art, Abbreviated, Saturday, January 4, 2025. I Saw The Very Wonderful Bob Dylan Biopic.

by Jon Katz

I have only one flower to put up as Flower Art; the day isn’t short enough for what I need to do.  See you tomorrow.

I went to the movies to see Timothee Chalamet’s A Complete Unknown. It is a beautifully and thoughtfully told story of Bob Dylan’s explosive beginning in New York City and ending with his betrayal of Pete Seeger’s Folk Music movement at the 1965 Newport Folk Festival.

Dylan has never been one to share the details of his youth and evolution as one of the greatest music song writers in history.

I am emotionally connected to this movie, which was touching, sad, and wonderfully portrayed. It is on the list of one of the best movies I’ve seen. I recommend it highly and thoroughly. Chalamet’s portrayal of a young, gifted, and awkward Dylan was perfect, as was the movie itself.

It struck home; I was living in Manhattan when Dylan arrived a block from Cafe Wha, where he and his lover Joan Baez met.

I saw him play there and felt the thrill of his songs and the hope they gave so many.  The movie marks the end of the struggling folk music movement – by then, stuffy and stuck –  and Dylan’s shift away from his brilliant anthem songs, which lit up a generation.

He didn’t want to repeat the same thing for the rest of his life, and he didn’t; good for him. Folk music had become constipated and self-righteous.

The movie begins when Dylan travels to New York from Minnesota to visit the Revered Folk Singer, Woody Guthrie, who is sick and dying in a New Jersey government home when Dylan arrives and walks into the hospital room. In the opening scene, Dylan enters the hospital and meets Seeger (Edward Norton), who is visiting his friend. Norton was wonderful.

Guthrie sang to the poor and forgotten of impoverished America, but Dylan didn’t care to take up that cause.

He made the music he wanted and gave his new outraged critics the finger. How sad that there is no Guthrie, and Dylan has abandoned his wondrous early works. Poor people in America could use a spiritual and musical leader, so could the rest of us.

Since Newport, Dylan has made more than 55 albums, many of them very good but none as powerful as Blowing In The Wind, Visions of Johanna, Like a Rolling Stone, etc.

Dylan’s tribute to the dying Guthrie – a legend I worshipped – left me in tears.

Mangold was wise to tell the story through music, not windy recollections from aging agents.

I’m too close to the time to write my usual detached and detailed review, but I bet Director James Mangold and Calamet get at least one Oscar Each.

Edward Norton was wonderful as the gentle Pete Seeger.

The movie broke my heart thinking of the lost idealism that one played so keen a role in music. So far, there is nothing to replace it.

I highly recommend it.  It was terrific up and down.

3 Comments

  1. Thanks, Jon, for this brief revue.
    I saw A Compete Unknown a couple of weeks ago. I was so moved by this film. I think that the best actor in it is Edward Norton, who played Pete Seeger. I think Calamet was the second best actor. I think Oscars nominations from this film should definitely be for Norton and Calamet, and James Mangold for best director. I really was moved so much that at the end of the film, I found my eyes to be wet.

    I really enjoyed the way Mangold did the film. He started it with no credits, waiting to the end of this 140 minute movie. It was great to see the young Dylan arriving in Manhattan to bein the movie. Mangold did change various things along the way, but the message was there. I thought all of those who played their roles did really well. This is a definite must see, and see. and see again. Don’t think twice, go to see this great film.

  2. Agree this film was wonderful. Acting great – and the music superb. When we hot home we took out our dvd titled “No Direction Home” a movie by Martin Scorese and narrated by Dylan himself. I guess we wanted to hear more of the music and Dylan’s story. Enjoyed all of it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Email SignupFree Email Signup