6 July

One Man’s Truth: Notes On A Man In Denial, A Nation In Crisis. Why The Biden Interview Failed.

by Jon Katz

I wanted to write this morning about President Biden’s effort last night in his ABC interview to assure Americans that he was cognitively and physically capable of being President of the United States, winning the November election, preserving our democracy, governing for four more arduous years, and saving the world from another Donald Trump presidency.

Despite the opportunity, President Biden’s ABC interview failed to convince me of his fitness for the presidency.

This failure will only fuel the growing movement to replace him, which will continue to gain momentum and support.

The stakes are too high, yet President Biden never acknowledged the potential consequences for the rest of us if he fails to win in November.

He was better prepared and more articulate than during his chilling disintegration during the debate.

However, the interview also exposed a different side of the President. He seemed almost desperate, resorting to typical and slick political tactics and deceiving himself and the public. His failure to prioritize the country’s interests over his own was a disappointing revelation.

He couldn’t remember if he even went back to look at his mental collapse during the debate: “I don’t think so,” he said when asked.  Didn’t he know?  He keeps pretending the problem was insufficient sleep, jet lag, working too hard, or the old favorite Trump target,  the media.

I can’t blame him for not watching the debate tapes, but it was perhaps the most revealing interview moment so far.

There was also his very telling statement about what the election is really about for him should he lose: “I’ll feel as long as  I gave it my all and I did the “goodest” job as I know I can do, that’s what this is about.”

Really?  The “best” job? Even Donald  Trump pretends his movement is for the good of the country, not just his ego.

We know by now that Trump is lying, but I thought – and so did many others – that Biden was a different kind of politician.  I can’t say I’m a fan of either man, but I always saw Biden as a decent and honest leader. I don’t see that Biden now.

I didn’t think his solution to this crisis would be to emulate Trump rather than defeat him. Many people had hoped, even prayed,  for a different approach, a different kind of leadership.

Politically speaking, the election is now not about his ego or even Trump’s.

It has come down to the core—will our democracy as we know it survive? Can God or his allies push Biden out? Consider what a gift it might be to the country if Biden quit the race and agreed to work hard to support his replacement. That would be a legacy of grace and patriotism, not denial and narcissism.

If you listen to or think about what people are saying, that’s what the election is about.

Biden did a bob and weave that reminded me of Muhammad Ali, the great boxer whose famous style was to move quickly up and down and from side to side to avoid hitting or being hit by something. It worked for Ali, who could move like a ballet dancer, but it isn’t and can’t work for President Biden, who moves, sounds, and thinks like a significantly older person.

He speaks so rapidly it sounds like he is scrambling to remember something and has only a few seconds to say it. His frantic campaigning has left him hoarse and difficult to understand. He seems to have no idea of what aging means.

Aging is not a political choice or matter of debate. It makes its own decisions in its own good time.

Biden also opened a window into his psyche last night by invoking God, something desperate politicians often do as they fight for their lives.  When you hear a politician invoke God, run for the exits, the end is near.

The president’s most quoted line in the interview was:  “Only the Lord Almighty” can drive him from the race. Is this decision really up to God and not Joe Biden?

If you believe in God, it seems to me, then one of God’s most potent and profound decisions was to create human beings who age, decline in mental and physical power, and inevitably die. God does not traditionally choose political candidates or manage debates, as I understand it, and in invoking him, Biden shows the shallowness of his much-evoked spirituality.

Perhaps he’s learning from his opponent. Trump has pulled off one of the most incredible hat tricks in all of politics, persuading millions of people who claim to be Christians that lying, being unfaithful, being a crook, and being a sexual predator are all signs that God sent him down to lead us.

Biden’s linking with God might be a more ingenious idea than it appears to be.

This isn’t a choice. It’s called life. In its own way, it is a sacred element of humanity.  Religious and spiritual people accept it.  To deny it seems a rejection of God, not an affirmation.

We are the only animals who know we will age and die. The only choice we have is how we will do it. That is grace.

That’s the real issue for President Biden, not his ducking and hiding behind an Army of protectors, handlers, and PR flacks.

I’m not sure if there is a God; it’s above my pay scale, but if there is, I am sure that he will not keep Biden from aging or from the universal decline of his cognitive and physical functions, already well underway.

I kept thinking about the same thing repeatedly as I listened to the interview and then listened to it again. Biden lied, evaded, denied, and dismissed.  I dream of something different.

He did not persuade me that he understood the apparent role of aging in his life. Aging is not something to be denied, especially for the leader of the Free World. It can not be dismissed or ducked.

 

.

The drama of being human is being born, being strong, getting older, losing skills and energy, getting sick, and then dying,  hopefully with grace.

Firing people because of their age is generally illegal, but numerous exceptions to the law exist. Biden cannot be fired from the federal government because of his age, but voters can decide if he is fit for the presidency or if his age is a factor.

As someone approaching his 77th birthday, I was sorry to watch Biden stuck in the aging trap of only being able to look back, not forward.

My life is fuller and happier than ever, but I have no delusions about my future. I can only do a few of the things I did even a year or so ago. I prefer to do the many things I can do in the “best” possible way. I am much closer to the end than the beginning; time has a different meaning.

The President showed no grace or humility in this interview or in his response to the tremendous damage caused by the debate. He doesn’t seem to grasp how afraid people are of his actions.

Over and over again, he repeated, mainly in a rapid-fire mumble, that the debate failure “was my fault, only me.” But Mr. President, that is the problem.

The debate was the beginning of this crisis, not the end.

I can speak only for myself.

I would never stand up in front of other humans and say the only measure of my capabilities is whether I do the “goodest” I can. It’s so much more complicated. (ABC later said the witches ideas not bestest Biden comment was mumbled to me)

I can only do things well if I accept the reality of my life and do not deny it, dismiss it, or lie about it. Doing good is fine, but it often asks us to think of others more than ourselves.

Watching Biden in his interview, I saw a rapidly aging man whose only plan was to brag about his past accomplishments.

The problem is that this plan differs from most Americans are worried about. People, even his many admirers, are apprehensive about the future, and Biden has nothing to say about that. The issue is the future, not the past. His debate performance scared the wits out of his followers, and anyone who feels democracy is worth saving.

Donald Trump has promised to be a dictator from his first day in office.

This is not politics as usual.

Watching Biden’s carefully produced and choreographed appearances has been painful these past few days. His aides are afraid to let him even try to be spontaneous or, God forbid, honest. His plea has no meaning.

He’s been all over the White House, Camp David, and presidential planes while much of America, both sides, cries out for change. We are once again being offered the same old thing—lies and a protected life within a cool of heavily guarded and programmed denial. It’s just more propaganda.

It won’t work because it can’t work. Biden is no longer the inspiration he is trying to be.

He is not the solution.

He has become the problem.

The Democratic Party is at a crossroads, and so is the country.

If they can’t muster the stranger or patriotism to force Joe Biden to step aside, God or no God,  our democracy and the people in it will pay a dear price for the President’s inability to see the truth about himself. And to take our democracy down with his ego lies and denial.

Do we have two political parties that can’t challenge a leader they don’t want and that nobody else wants?

Yes, it’s hard to imagine how we got into this mess with two ancient, declining candidates running who seem to care only about themselves. But here we are.

19 Comments

  1. This should have been resolved months ago. His wife and inner circle have witnessed his cognitive decline and chose to hide it from the public. He should have taken himself out of the running long ago and allowed for a vibrant primary campaign. Alas. Thank you for putting my feelings into words.

  2. I’m disappointed in Biden, and his inner circle. I know aging isn’t all that easy to accept but it’s just life. To cost a country it’s democracy because you can’t accept the inevitable is going to ruin Biden’s legacy. I too caught the fact that he didn’t know if he watched the debate. Give me a break.

  3. “Beautiful statement and Philosophy! To deny the facts of life is just
    a foolish effort which will inevitably be cleared by future understanding.
    Its time to examine and accept reality.
    Thanks, ” This was a friend’s reply and I agree. Thank you Jon for adding great insight to this situation.

  4. As a former leadership coach in organizations, it is difficult to fathom that his advisors would not insist he view the debate, as well as watch it along with him, giving him a critique. Watching yourself in this situation is the best way to make corrections and succeed. I was struck with his response in the interview. Again, it appears as if he had little preparation. When asked about taking a cognitive ability test, he could have said that if my physician orders it, I will take one. Like you, I was disappointed and hope he realizes he needs to step aside. He is a good man and a successful president. Leaving would be a win, not a defeat.

  5. Biden did not say the “goodest job,”:he said the “good as job.” Please avoid these cheap shots.

    1. No, he said “gooiest job,” Blair, according to the ABC transcript and the New York Times.

      1. Jon, the NYTimes just reported that ABC changed the transcript to read “as good a job”. It was changed Saturday afternoon.

        1. Yes, I know, it’s in some dispute and I changed it to reflect that. I listened to the tape again, and it is impossible to know exactly what Biden is saying, which is part of the problem. I’m not interested in these side squawks, what’s important is the main event.

  6. Biden on a bad day is still better than Trump on a good day. But not by much. At least we’d still have our democracy. If Biden continues to run and is defeated by Trump, I will blame the Democratic Party for not forcing Biden to see himself as the rest of us do and for not coming up with a viable candidate. Surely there is a Democratic governor or member of Congress who could do the job. I wonder if VP Harris would be interested.

  7. It is said that Queen Elizabeth believed the same thing…..Only God could remove her from the throne. The problem for the US is that we are removing a president and the other guy is a nightmare. I really admire Biden…he has been a great president. And I can’t imagine the effort it will take to switch to another candidate. But it needs to be done…too much is at stake…Unlike the Republican’s, Democrats are not a cult…we have such a big tent. Surely we can find someone else.

  8. Your statement that corporations require employees to retire between 65 and 70 is incorrect. Forcing people to retire on the basis of age is forbidden by the Age Discrimination in Employment Act.

  9. It is all so sad and it should never have been allowed to happen. Pilots have to retire after a certain age. It’s a safety issue. But I would think the safety of our country is at least as important. I would love for Mr Biden to have retired with a great record of 4 years. I just cannot understand the party officials who drive their leaders. It is all a sordid game. I am truly sick of it.

  10. Excellent blog piece! Very insightful. It is unfortunate that some of those around him, especially his wife, are enabling him/his inability to face his aging , and the repercussions of running again! Thank you for writing this piece.

  11. Thanks, Jon, for this excellent essay. You are so correct. We must remember that old saying “Denial is not a river in Africa.” That river is 4,000 miles long. The denials of both Trump and Biden are challenging it’s length. Come on, Democratic party, get your act together instead of joining that denial.

  12. How our judgments and predictions go wrong.
    “Nate Silver was right about the 2016 primaries: they were remarkable, if not exactly “epic.” But he was quite wrong, too: his FiveThirtyEight site dismissed Donald Trump’s candidacy, insisting that the blustery Queens real estate tycoon and reality TV star stood no chance of winning the Republican nomination. Silver, the wonky data journalist who made a reputation with his pinpoint forecasts of presidential elections in 2008 and 2012, flubbed the Trump ascendancy, keeping company with many other media analysts, pundits, and presumed authorities.
    .

    “Our emphatic prediction,” Silver wrote in August 2015, months before the Republican primary elections, “is simply that… . Lost in a Gallup: Polling Failure in U.S. Presidential Elections W. Joseph Campbell

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Email SignupFree Email Signup