19 December

First Report: Toilet Chronicle. We Love It. I Believe It’s The Future, Even For The Rich

by Jon Katz

I never thought of loving a toilet before, but I am happy with our new composting toilet in our bedroom. So is Maria.

(Photo, our bedroom 5 a.m. The toilet is on the other side of the door.)

It will not only prevent falls down the stairs one day while rushing to the bathroom, but it is easy, sanitary, inexpensive, and practical in the climate change era. The toilet is just what the manufacturers say and promised. No surprises.

I never thought of writing about a toilet either, but guess what – it’s a beautiful picture at night when the light inside is one and our former outhouse door peers into the night. I thank my photography, which brings life to truth and reality.

We did need to build a small bathroom around the toilet, which is in a corner of our rather large bedroom. We couldn’t afford to take the house apartment upstairs for new plumbing, and there was no reason to. Our new toilet does everything the others do except flush.

A surprising number of people have been writing to ask me how Maria and I feel about the toilet, something I never even heard of a year ago. Our Nature’s Head composting toilet went operational Sunday; as of now, we have used it at least once.

I’m trying to be delicate about this, but I promised to share the experience, so I will say we’ve only urinated, no bowel movements for now.

We have a bathroom downstairs, so this toilet will have limited use – at night and in emergencies; Maria can speak for herself and has, on her blog.

We are happy with the cost, clarity, ease of use, and structure that Dan Rogers built around it. The toilet makes sense in many ways, at least for us. We have no complaints. Maria will put her artistic genius to work and make the room warm and colorful.

There are only two of us; we live in a small farmhouse and have a working bathroom downstairs. Looking down the road, it seems wise to have a bathroom upstairs, as older people often need to do. It isn’t something I like talking about, either. But it’s important and hopefully useful.

Being open is being open. The blog is the story of my life and the people who enter it, and eliminating is a universal experience. It’s a creative challenge to write about it.

If you are like me, I’d recommend hiring an experienced plumber, carpenter, or handyman to help set it up. It wasn’t a problem for Maria, but it was beyond me.

Once set up, it is almost shockingly simple to use.

It is well-built, solid to sit on, and straightforward to clean. If needed, you can drop toilet paper into the bowel opening, separate from the urine bucket.

I’m persuaded that there will be no odor. The toilet is self-contained.

The bucket has no odor to date; we always have the fan on as suggested (it’s silent and draws very little power). The fan takes any odor outside and keeps the composting material moist. It has to be moist to absorb the waste matter.

We spray water and vinegar into the town after each use. The composting material – we use coco coir – comes in small blocks (very inexpensive) and needs soaking in water before use. The company recommends using the cheapest toilet paper, it is absorbed more quickly than the good stuff.

The bowel section, as I call it, is emptied but otherwise self-cleansed.

The composting is done in the bowel movement compartment.

If it’s not used much (ours won’t be),  the compost is removed every month or two by putting a 13-gallon garbage bag over the compartment, turning it over into the bag, and taking it out to the compost heap; if you have one.

The urine bucket needs cleansing with a cleansing spray. The company recommends water and vinegar.

I was nervous about using this new toilet but quickly overcame it. It’s comfortable and easy.  It’s just like going to the bathroom. Men should sit down on the toilet, not urinate standing up.

Almost anyone, even young children, could use this toilet. Still, it’s especially timely and relevant to camping, traveling in RVs, living in tiny homes, or living in old ones like ours without much solid plumbing. I believe a toilet is the future, for all kinds of reasons.

All kinds of people are using these toilets now, and from the reviews I’ve read, they like them. They are drawing much attention in states where water is becoming a major political issue.

I’ll keep providing updates, but I wanted to write and say this has gone very well so far, and we are 100 percent pleased with it. I write this hoping to be helpful as long as people want to hear about it.

1 Comments

  1. There is nothing wrong with being explicit about this new toilet’s use.

    We are looking to buy a house in the nearby future here in Canada and a lot of the listings within our financial reach are of older homes. They may have been renovated but quite a few are like your farmhouse: outfitted with only one humble bathroom/toilet.

    I grew up in a house like that and the only option I had as a child was to have a little plastic potty with lid with me, so that I did not have to climb down the stairs. It was not just the safest option, it also means less time spent in the cold of the unheated upstairs. Quick trip on the potty and back to bed. Not the most fun part of the day though to navigate the stairs with a not-empty bucket. My mom did not mind doing that but she still lives in this house and when I stay over the routine is unchanged. And I clean my own mess, but I cannot say I enjoy it…

    Of course, these days, with all of us over here on the American continent, used to so much luxury, many city people would be appalled to hear about routines like that. And we too currently live in an overly luxurious rental with ensuite in the master. One gets used to this type of comfort quickly. And it can come as a shock to find so many houses with just single facilities.

    Because of our future plans, I have been following your toilet stories with extreme interest.
    I may come from a country of origin where things are named as they are, but here in this part of the world I often find language so cosmetically smoothed out, that often it does not describe reality. So thank you for being open and honest and publishing pictures. I have actually shown them to our realtor and she is probably following your blog now too, if only for the toilet adventure 🙂

    The house we are interested in has one small bathroom with one toilet and a small shower on the main level. Nothing upstairs, nothing in the finished part of the basement, where the main bedroom would be.
    I don’t know if we will be able to afford this place, but if we do, we would definitely consider renovating. So we asked for tentative quotes, just to know what our cost would be. And let me tell you: It IS in fact very expensive. A simple toilet room like yours upstairs would come to 14,000 over here in Canada, and this is without tax. To have something more luxurious in the basement (where the main bedroom would be) or on the main level would be round 26,000. And that would be with default furniture, nothing fancy. And the number is without tax as well. Some of the cost has to do with the fact that houses simply do not have the require plumbing. That makes it a lot more expensive.

    Compare that to the purchase of a compost toilet and an hourly rate to have the room built and it is clear which is more cost efficient. Saves water too. Not a bad thing either.

    Males sitting down to pee: another excellent subject to be open about. My husband grew up with 2 sisters and was simply told to always sit down to pee because it makes less of a mess. And I am grateful for that. Whenever we have male guests in the house, it is a hard subject to address so I usually spray clean the powder room after they have left and this is no luxury. So I hope lots of males take this into consideration, if only for hygienic reasons. According to my husband it makes no difference to the peeing experience. Others may disagree… As a female I cannot say which is which…

    I love how your toiletroom looks – I did not realise it was right there in your main bedroom. I thought it was in a spare room. But the old door sure makes it look nice. If ever you have need to use the number 2 facilities I am curious to hear if it actually IS odorless, so do keep us posted.

    Great subject to address openly!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Email SignupFree Email Signup