5 February

Daphne, My Sister’s Dog. Jane And I Will Never Abandon One Another

by Jon Katz

I didn’t see the text until early this morning; it was sent to me yesterday at 2:27 p.m. There was no message attached, just a photo of a dog I recognized as my sister’s dog, Daphne; Jane sends me a picture of Daphne every few months.

I didn’t realize until yesterday that she wanted me to post the photo on my blog.

She is proud of Daphne, a Pyrenees/Anatolian Shepherd bred to guard livestock. Daphne didn’t pass the toughness test, and that’s how my sister got her. Her new life is watching over Jane in her new home living with friends the way up New York State. I don’t know the address.

Jane is one of the most intelligent people I’ve ever known and one of the most gentle and vulnerable. I spent years of my young life trying to help her, and the truth is, I never could.

Whenever I watch all these sappy movies about family, my heart sinks a bit when everyone ends happily.

The message is always the same – family is more important than anything else; it is the place you go when no one will take you in and you have no place to go. Every story must end happily, even in the most troubled families, with a dramatic and teary reconciliation.

That is not my family’s story, or I suspect many others.

Family is a painful and insoluble puzzle for many, including Maria and me.

Those people never get their story told. Sad family stories make for a bad box office and poor ratings. In that world, no matter what, the family has to win in the end.

My sister and I were always close and powerfully connected to the witness we bore to one another’s lives and childhoods. We are bound closely together as we are the only ones who witnessed the struggles and pain of the other. We are each other’s memory and truth.

But our relationship is never simple; we often each trigger for the other, so we speak rarely and carefully. I don’t know how to talk to her, and she has the same trouble. But we never give up. We keep trying.

I haven’t seen Jane in years and don’t expect to see her again in my life or hers. She is happy now, safe and content, living with friends who built a room for her and watched over her closely and lovingly.

I was not a part of that move, but when I talked to Jane, I was thrilled to learn how happy and safe she was.

She got to where she needed to be and wanted to be with people who loved her and cared for her.

She deserves every ounce of happiness that she can find, and my only regret is that I could never help her as much as I wanted.

I think we feel that way about each other. Jane was the person I always ran away with, and we always ended up at the same place, my grandmother’s house.

We ran away in protest but never really had any place to go. We never got as far as we wished to go.

Jane and I would whisper to one another in our rooms as we heard the shouts and screams of my parent’s ferocious arguments downstairs.

Jane and I don’t know all that much about each other anymore. She points out that she doesn’t ever read the blog because she doesn’t want to know me “that way,” although I don’t know what that means. She is busy and never calls; sometimes, she texts. But it turns out she does care about the blog, at least for Daphne.

People who want to know nothing about my blog and my writing aren’t going to know me all that well. So the space between us feels wide.

Our most significant trouble is that talking to each other is often just too painful. It just stirs up old things we both are eager to leave behind.

That’s where we are, and that, I think, is where we shall stay.

This is a hard thing to write for me. But it’s essential.

I call Jane every month, and we talk while driving until I get to the market or a doctor’s appointment. We catch up and then hang up. I know she is pleased and proud of her dog Daphne.

When I asked her today why she was texting me photos of Daphne when I never heard from her otherwise, she said she wanted me to put Daphne up on her blog.

The blog is a sacred thing to me; it also connects me to my daughter. It connects me to my sister in different ways. It is a part of me now.

An unbearable but inseparable life binds Jane and me. We will never abandon one another.

Despite our troubles, then and now, we love each other dearly and always will. We both know that.

That is never on the table.

She loves Daphne very much.

So here she is, a beautiful dog who keeps good on my sister, something I could never do.

Hey, Jane.

9 Comments

  1. Hello John,
    I have read several of your books, and enjoyed them . I have envied your farm from far away, but enjoy the space my hubby and I have.
    My hubby has been having intermittent dreams of our old yellow Lab. We had to have him put down about 12 years ago. I had never seen your blog before in my Facebook site. I wonder if there’s some cosmic connection, as seeing your blog has made me remember when you wrote about contacting animal communicator to help with your feelings following Orson’s death.
    Thank you for your stories and compassion.
    Ellen

  2. Jon, this is a wonderful commentary on a very sad and difficult life that many experience in life which we do not put into words. You have and beautifully so. While I can’t relate to tragedy in my childhood life, I can in my adult life and that you have experienced this with Jane, your sister, as you say, will bind you in a way forever in this life. You’ve honoured her here and your words of your childhoods, both of you, are so very sad and poignant. What kept parents together in those days was the stigma of divorce and the disallowing for this happening. Life has many twists and turns, doesn’t it. It’s how we cope with it that matters. You’re very fortunate, both you and Maria to have found your place in the country and in your lives together.
    Sandy Small Proudfoot,

  3. Lordy – family is such a loaded topic. What I’ve learned is that each child in a family experiences that family differently than the others. This depends entirely on the temperament of the child, and what drama is going on at the time of their birth. Birth order is a thing, but trauma (what happened to us, and/or what we didn’t get that we needed) is a much more determinant force in the life of a child. I agree, talking with some of my siblings only brings up stuff from the past that should just stay there. Thank you for sharing your journey with your sister, Jon. Helps me feel normal.

  4. This is so beautiful and heart-catching. This family story is very common, and too often unheard, but it’s spoken beautifully right here. It feels very special today, to see the picture that Jane has reached out and shared for your blog of us readers like a pure offering. Heartfelt thanks and best to both of you, M

  5. very profound post, Jon. Even the shared childhood connection and bonds that we had (or have) cannot *make* the relationship any different than it is now. To *wish* for that is futile, as it has taken me many years to learn and accept. I share a similar, if not quite as distant, relationship with my only remaining *family*, my brother. All we can do is continue to love each other in our own way and share what is possible and comfortable at this point in time for each of us.
    Susan M

  6. I’m a devoted though not good at saying thank you reader…..thank you for the lessons and the insights and the pure love that you show to your animals and to your Maria:…and to the feeling that I am always left with after you open your heart…
    Gives me hope in the human race that there is
    such a man as you in the world
    I also have a question John….did you not post two lovely drawings of gnomes…something my artistic granddaughter would love to see….
    Where might I find them again….thank you for so much…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Email SignupFree Email Signup