27 December

Back Home From A Wonderful Night At Our Safe Place, Where We Honeymooned, Where Anxiety Goes To Hide

by Jon Katz

The old inn in Vermont has always been one of our safest places from the beginning. We went there on our honeymoon 14 years ago.

We have returned at least once a year (except during the pandemic), and it was the perfect place to go after last week’s storm, which left both of us drained and exhausted.

My fear dribbled away even before we got there.

Fear is a sentient creature with instincts, if not conventional intelligence. Born in our earliest days, we are either soothed or ignored. I have come to understand that humans have always faced fear, pressure, and dangers, and I believe some fear is passed down to all of us.

I am the grandchildren of Jewish refugees from Europe. Fear was always a part of my growing up. The world never seems to tire of persecuting Jews and demonizing them.

It seems to be something broken humans need.

All of us know fear. Some of us are known and soothed; many are not.

Fear is alive, present in us, and urgent need of nourishment. Sometimes I see it as a sentient being.

For me, fear has always jumped opportunistically from one thing to another – money, work, anger, failure, humiliation, isolation, and emotional bleeding. For anxiety, one is as good as another.

It just doesn’t like to go without.

The best thing I have learned to do with fear is to accept it and try to understand where it comes from. Eventually, it goes away or recedes because fear is one thing and panic is another.

I have to live with fear; I won’t live for long with terror. Fear is an emotion.

The old inn was a tonic. it was just what we needed, an old friend with a safe space to offer us.

Maria lay down with a book and fell asleep before I could unpack.

My psychological guide and hero when it comes to anxiety is British Psychoanalyst John Bowlby whose much embraced theory of attachment (it applies to people and dogs also) suggests that children come into the world biologically pre-programmed to form attachments with others because this is necessary for them to survive.

Some attachments – like the one to a mother – are much more important than others.

Bowlby also wrote about the maternal deprivation hypothesis, which suggests that continuing disruption between the infant and primary caregivers can result in long-term cognitive, social, and emotional difficulties for that infant.

Nothing is more vulnerable in our world than a newborn child, who is not only often terrified but unable to speak or understand the fear.

If the mother doesn’t hear the child or sense its fear and comfort it, anxiety grows and depeens Bowlby, and is integrated into the psychic formation of the child.

You can bet that Donald Trump was emotionally disconnected from his mother.

This is a terror without words, or comprehension, which leaves adults like me bewildered about what happened to make me so frightened.

All it takes is a mother who doesn’t grasp the child’s anxiety and can’t or won comfort the baby. I embrace this theory and believe this happened to Maria and me.

When we met, Maria and I were both struck by the fact that we seemed to know one another and sense the love and fear in the other.

We have both been waiting for someone to know us our whole lives. This opened the gate to our falling in love, getting married, and loving each other more often.

We were what the other needed and could never find.

When I get frightened, Maria senses it and tells me she knows, is present, and will be there for me. I do the same for her. It works. It is a powerful medicine, as powerful as a decade of talking therapy, which I also believe in.

Fear is always inside of me, looking for a place to land. If I sense it in one place, it just moves to another. I go beneath it to the source.

To the frightened infant who was alone and scared and very heard or known. The fear grew up alongside me and will die inside of me.

But I have come to know it just as it has come to know me. And the better I see and understand it, the less power and sting it has. I don’t expect to be entirely rid of it; it is part of the human experience.

But when we got to our inn, the fear was gone inside me, it didn’t return until I was almost home, and the wheels started turning – bills, obligations, chores, responsibilities.

I hear you, said Maria, you are safe here, and I will be right with you. And it went away again.

At the inn, Maria read me from an ancient copy of Walt Whitman’s Leaves of Grass; she found it in a reading room in the inn.

We had a wonderful dinner. We stayed up for hours reading, laughing, and watching stupid TV, something we never do at home.

She fell in love with the new bathtub in our favorite room, soaked in it for hours, and came out as mellow as I have ever seen. And I have not seen her mellow often.

We slipped all tangled up in one another, laughed and told stories, and regained our strength, will, and energy, much of which the angry storm sucked out of us.

It is our safe place, we return to it repeatedly, and it empowers and refreshes us.

The sun was shining when we got back home; we had to get bandages for Lulu; I ran to the bookstore to get a copy of The Magic Kingdom by Russell Banks, a favorite author. I’ll be up reading it until the very wee hours tonight.

I love getting back to my blog; it is where I feel most heard. It is a safe place for me and a healing one. Two days ago, I was almost paralyzed by fear.

I am most at ease and powerful when I join the community of practitioners, infused with the energy of awareness and empathy, and compassion.

When I feel part of a spiritual community of seekers, I can feel joy and push back the old temptation to succumb to fear and despair.

I have something better in mind to feel than that.

Today, I was back to myself and my good and blessed life. The wheel turns and turns.

I supposed this is the story of life.

11 Comments

  1. Lovely to hear you both feel rejuvenated. What I heard, about your connection to each other, I’ve read about as “trauma bonding.” It’s powerful stuff, and when both of you are healing, it’s a darn near a magical way to live. It’s a life of gratitude!

  2. Going someplace where you have no responsibilities; a favorite restaurant; friend’s home;; comfortable inn with precious memories. These restore the body, the soul, and the spirit. You can return home renewed and more able to face whatever. Glad you have renewed energy and you are looking ahead.

  3. It looks like that’s snow out the window in Vermont.

    Re your “The world never seems to tire of persecuting Jews and demonizing them….. It seems to be something broken humans need.” Evolutionarily we needed to bond with our own group, thus we are still tribal and, when under stress, we resort to hyperbonding with our own group and rejecting the outsider. Hopefully most of us have grown beyond that state, but many — e.g., Trump’s “base” — have not and those who exploit the Trump base type. As long as a society we do not model as community and individuals respect for diverse humans, and help those with few opportunities with financial and other support to grow beyond the tribe, we will continue to have small minded haters of the outsider.

    I am a Bowlby fan too. But there is too much blame on the mother in your interpretation of Bowlby. What the new born needs is a “primary caregiver” — usually the mother but not necessarily — who is deeply attuned to the child (called “secure attachment” by some). It does not have to be the biological mother; it is often aunt or grandma or uncle or stepmom, … I think of John Lennon whose uncle served that purpose. But your interpretation does explain your hostility to women expressed in your blog occasionally. What is impressive about Bowlby unlike Freud, Bowlby did research on his theory. Freud just projected his own views without relevant research.

    The “deprived” child can behave “as if” the attachment was secure and in that way, and also by becoming friends with supportive people (teachers, etc) that fantasy strengthens him and builds his inner resources. Otherwise the child is likely to develop anxiety, depression and numerous neuroses to compensate.

    1. Thanks, Charles; I don’t agree that Bowlby blames the mother for all of their childhood troubles. I certainly don’t. That is not a lecture I need.

      I believe the bond between mother and child is unique and precious and can have lasting effects when it has broken, and I also know that from my own life. Blaming mothers for all neuroses is ignorant and a waste of time.

      I can’t imagine how that meticulously researched observation can get hung up in PC science. The truth still matters. I’ve studied Bowlby and attachment research for years, and to say Bowlby is anti-mother is a gross misrepresentation of his work (and mine.)

      Of course, deprived children can find valuable relationships with other people, as I have, that seems quite obvious to me and in no way contracts Bowlby’s observations. He did not partake in the culture wars. But there is no other relationship like the one between the person who gives birth to a child and here child, who is so connected to them in this remarkable, beautiful, and unique way. .

  4. I needed this today. Fear is often in my life right now, and like a favorite quote of mine from the book Dune, fear is the mind killer. Unlike you, I don’t feel there is anyone in my life right now who understands and cherishes me, but fear must be walked through and there is usually brightness on the other side.

  5. Good article until once again you ad to say something about Trump even though you have no idea anything about his childhood. Shame on you. Very judgey comment from someone who has felt judged.

    1. Rachel, there are several good books about Trump’s childhood and life beyond, I think the best one I read was by his niece Mary Trump, who interviewed living members of his family in her best-selling book about his childhood and adulthood https://www.amazon.com/TOO-MUCH-NEVER-ENOUGH-DANGEROUS/dp/1471190137/ref=asc_df_1471190137/?tag=hyprod-20&linkCode=df0&hvadid=475789621852&hvpos=&hvnetw=g&hvrand=18006153486973406357&hvpone=&hvptwo=&hvqmt=&hvdev=c&hvdvcmdl=&hvlocint=&hvlocphy=9004948&hvtargid=pla-921128787299&psc=1.

      Another one I would recommend is “Born Trump” by Emily Jane Fox.
      I’m not sure why you take it on yourself to tell me what I have or have not read since you clearly have no idea. I make observations about many people (including you), which is my writing job. Trump had a very rough time with his parents; by all accounts, they were cruel and very distant. His father was remote and demanding, and very cold.
      His mother was deeply troubled.

      This actually speaks very directly to what I wrote, although you missed it. Do a bit of homework before blowing smoke out of your ass. And don’t be ashamed of yourself; you’re just lazy; that’s social media, and you picked a bad horse. If you follow attachment theory, which I have, Trump has every right to be the awful mess he is.

  6. Thanks for sharing the journey. I think your blog helps many people feel that their own spiritual journeys are valuable and we’re all walking them together, if we’re honest.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Email SignupFree Email Signup