13 November

When Family Is “Everything.” The Holiday Season And The Secret Society Of People With No Families

by Jon Katz

Family isn’t one thing; it’s everything, said Michael J. Fox in an interview, the kind every movie star gives at one time or another.

When everything goes to hell, the people who stand by you without flinching are your family,” wrote Ken Butcher.

I often read quotes like this, they are everywhere, and I don’t think I’ve ever seen a Hollywood family movie ending without tear-filled forgiveness and reconciliation, always reconciliation.

The idea is that family is everything, more important than anything, even when the children are abandoned, abused, or forgotten.

One recent family movie won an Oscar.

It showed a mother pushing her daughter out of a speeding car, and in the end, the daughter was on the phone, forgiving her and trading promises of love and devotion.

Parents and families are forgiven everything, except for one thing: not reconciling at the end and not forgiving. After all, family is everything; nothing in life can ever be more important.

They are the people who must always take you in when the roof falls in.

Maria and I have seen endings and portrayals like this all of our lives together, and it often makes us wince and turn to one another in confusion and some sorrow.

We are isolated this way; our family stories do not and will not have happy endings. Family isn’t everything to us; sadly, it isn’t anything. We don’t see family on holidays or at any other time. They are not in our lives.

When our lives have gone to hell, as both of ours have, the family never stood by; they just flinched and disappeared. We never ran back to them.

We aren’t getting that family ending. I didn’t speak to either of my parents in the years before they died, and they were never present when I needed them, which was fine with me.

I never trusted them enough to need them.

I don’t like to speak for Maria, she has her own sad stories to tell about families, and she isn’t headed for that Happy Hollywood happy ending either.

This is not a happy or gloating or easy thing to say. I’m not proud of it. But I am glad about it.

We both did what we needed to do to survive, and that was to get away from our families. Neither of us has ever regretted it, although it has made us sad and sometimes disconnected from the wider world.

One blog reader said she loved us because our lives were off-center, which is one of the many reasons why – our families are not a part of our lives.

We both understand that we will get to a point in life where we won’t get those Hollywood endings, there won’t be a reconciliation, and there will be no one there to help or save us or help us except for the love, trust, and life we each helped give to one another and found in some other people.

It’s awful to lose one’s family, but finding and building another one is possible.

Every day, one of us looks to the other and says, “you are my family,” which is true. And we are everything to one another that we never got from our families. Maria, in particular, has made some wonderful friends. It isn’t so easy for me.

To my surprise, I have discovered that many of us out there have no families in our lives and don’t get that Hollywood ending or don’t say family is everything to us.

The holiday season brings this very much to mind. The family worship has already begun and will get worst by the day.

I have a daughter, and we are close. I love her, and she is family.

But it’s not the Hollywood family we see all the time on the tube; we live far apart and have separate lives.

But she is the only family I can say are in my life. I am grateful for that.

I haven’t spoken to my brother in years, and my sister hasn’t called me in memory. I call her once in a while to ensure she’s okay. She is.

When she broke her hip, I sent some money. That’s about it. I don’t want to speak to my brother ever again.

A shrink told me that when I realized I couldn’t be near my mother anymore, I had begun what she called a “Transition” from one life to another. It was necessary, she said; it was sad, but it was healthy.

She said it is a much more common occurrence than most people are led to believe. The “Transition” from mother to life is necessary for some people to live their own lives and find their purpose for living.

My life began when I got away from my family; only then could I heal and find the life I wanted. Maria and I were in the same boat when we met; we instantly became family to one another. Both of us are happier than we ever were around our families.

I believe her art blossomed when she made her Transition into the life she wanted, not that others wanted for her.

I didn’t know what love and happiness were until I left my family behind, and I realized they had left me much earlier.

In our culture, the family must pull together; it’s the only ending people will tolerate or pay to see and read. But often, it’s just a fairy tale.

. Nobody wants to see or stream a movie about broken or dysfunctional families and stay that way. The family story must always have a happy ending.

But as we are often reminded, Hollywood is not life. It is Hollywood.

I’ve come to see that we are not alone; we are a part of a family of people without family.

The people like us don’t like to talk about our families and don’t fit into the often sappy dimension portrayed of family life. You never hear from them or see them in the movies. When we have dinner with friends, our families never come up.

It’s almost a secret society.

Many of our family-less friends gather on holidays like Thanksgiving or Christmas. They call themselves fellow orphans.

But you wouldn’t know they were there if you weren’t one of them.

We try to fulfill some of the holes left behind by all the warm and happy ideas about family.

In a sense, we are orphans, refugees, alone in the world except for one another and the friends we have made. They are essential; they mean a lot.

I write this with no joy or satisfaction; sometimes, my heart yearns for the family I lost and the very idea of family that is so important to “normal” people.

I want to say that the real Hell for me came when I was close to myself, and when I left my family, I found peace, love, joy, and meaning I never imagined. It’s never easy or pain-free, but it can be done. People caught in awful family situations, and miserable should know that.  Any therapist will tell you they are out there.

But my heart is also filled with joy and meaning for my true family now, which includes Maria, other off-center people, dogs, donkeys, and many people I have never met face to face. It’s a loyal and loving family. It’s my family.

The holiday season is the toughest for me, and I think, for Maria. This hot and unrelenting celebration of the family is all around us, everywhere we go or look.

I am never sure how to feel about this; the holiday season is a time of love, generosity, and healing for me. I wish it could have been different. I’m grateful I got away.

Maria and I are going off for a day right after Christmas to the place we honeymooned more than a decade ago.

We will celebrate with our small but loving family there, give thanks to each other and think about the crisis, mystery, and joy of life.

11 Comments

  1. Hollywood isn’t reality & it’s good to remember that now & then. I love my parents, but I also hate them occasionally when I remember certain things they did or failed to do. They have passed from this life now & my only brother & I have never seen eye to eye on anything. I haven’t seen him in years & we seldom communicate. I have a husband & 4 grown kids. Holidays are often tense & difficult due to, let’s say, clashing personalities. I used to say, & sometimes still do to myself, Christmas in Saudi Arabia (where there isn’t any) sounds good to me!

  2. Thanks so much for the depth you bring in your writing. I have loved you for many years now through your books and your blog. I have felt for many years that we are family or at least familiar. I love you, Jon.

  3. I can relate. As someone who felt profound relief when my parents died, I often feel like an outsider looking in. I get so tired of the assumption that so many people make that all of us have wonderful parents. I must confess that I take a perverse kind of pleasure in responding to Hallmark sentiments on occasions like Mother’s Day with a simple “I was relieved when she died.”
    There is a huge injustice being done in family court where an abusive parent (usually the father) gets custody of the children because the other parent must have alienated them . I believe that this stems from the same place that leaves people unable to comprehend that not all parents are benign and that we must love people even when they are toxic to our very soul. Thank goodness we can create our own surrogate families.

  4. As I was reading, I heard myself saying (in my mind) “but you and Maria are a wonderful family!”
    But I realize you were referring to your families of origin, and I remember when I first realized, as you said, that we can create a family of our choice, as you and Maria have.
    I know there’s no fairytale ending for me, and no close family at all, but I am grateful for the friends who have chosen me as family. I am so happy that you two have been so good together.

  5. Hi Jon, thank you for addressing this topic as it is difficult to be surrounded by all the “family centered” celebrations that are shown on TV or in the movies that focus on the togetherness of family sharing laughs and conversation but I also feel sad that i don’t have this with my own family now due to extenuating circumstances. I do look at what I have with my husband, close friends, and my dogs…they are my family and I love them. I sincerely hope you and Maria keep enjoying each other in your beautiful surroundings with your dogs, and the close ties that you have with friends…..this wonderful portrayal of your family unit is extremely important and most of all, these components of your life provide you both with the love and closeness that defines… “family”.

  6. I remember once, years ago, telling my therapist about something I had seen or read about the strong bonds between brothers. I told I wished I had that with my brothers and that I wished I had strong feelings about family. He chuckled a bit (perfectly appropriately for the relationship we had) and said to me, “You have strong feelings about family. They’re just all negative.” That was a good 30 years or so ago. Nothing much has changed since then, I’m afraid.

  7. Another meaningful post, Jon, thank you. I heard this all my life: “Family is all we have!” and it has taken many years of therapy and boundary work to let go of that toxic tribal dogma. I have created the family I wanted, by selecting people that are kind, loving, and growing. It took a lot of therapy to let go of my resentment that I didn’t have the family that I wanted; they may have been able to be different, but they weren’t and aren’t and I love them, but don’t have to like them or see them. It feels good to be free of the burden of old beliefs.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Email SignupFree Email Signup