30 October

What Makes For A Spiritual Man Or Woman. The Things That We Love Tell Us Who We Are

by Jon Katz

The problem I and so many others have always had with spirituality is the idea that only saints can be truly spiritual. People who never get angry or say or do anything they regret. Those of us with complex or mercurial temperaments are deemed to be too human to be truly spiritual.

I’ve been working on my spirituality for decades now; it was Thomas Merton and his writing that drew me to the country in the first place; like him, I yearned for solitude and the space and quiet to think and meditate about who I wished to be.

I admit that I did think a bolt of lightning from God would get me where I wanted to go, a holy moment, a moment of revelation,  a burst of light, and I would be a truly spiritual man, a man of peace and love and compassion.

That, I know now, is Hollywood’s idea of the spiritual man; it is not reality.

After years of working on it, I remain a person with A schizophrenia temperament, lurching back and forth from anger and anxiety to peace and empathy.

“Well,” said a friend, a fellow seeker, “at least you are interesting.”

I am a person of Temperament; there is a lot of anger and intolerance in me, it bursts out now and then, and sometimes there are bursts of love and compassion in me. I think both occupy equal parts of my soul, and I sometimes despair of shedding the angry one. I’m not even sure it’s something I ought to go.

I’ve learned to love myself if I ever wish to be loved. I am who I am; I don’t believe I can become someone else. I don’t believe I want to.

I forgot for a while what Merton wrote about it and remembered it recently: “Temperament does not predestine one man to sanctity and another to reprobation. All temperaments can serve as the material for ruin or salvation. We must learn to see that our Temperament is a gift of God, a talent with which we must trade until He comes.”

Merton taught me that I didn’t have to be a saint to be a spiritual person. He acknowledged that he had much anger and doubt in him. He fought with his bishop for many years.

It doesn’t matter how complicated a temperament I might be endowed with. If I make good use of what I have, if I make it serve my better angels and desires, I can do better than someone who merely serves his Temperament instead of making it serve him.

I often get angry in the name of good, and I am coming to terms with this. I sometimes get more done in that way; I do not have a subservient or worshipful personality.

But I do wish to do good and have done more than I ever imagined possible, even as the flawed and confused person I am.

I hate no human being – expect possibly hypocrites, the lowest form of life on the earth to me – but there are things about our society that I dislike intensely.

The elderly have been abandoned; they struggle primarily alone in the darkness. More and more, we blame the poor for being poor and the refugee for being desperate.

As a culture, we have turned away from empathy and towards grievance, anger, and judgment.

We have forgotten – many Christians especially –  Jesus’s call from the mount to care for the needy and the vulnerable.

For me, spirituality is just the opposite: it is about mercy and forgiveness at its core. You do good when you can, and as much as you can.

I was relieved to understand that I didn’t need to be a saint to be a spiritual person; I just needed to want to be spiritual and to do good. That’s all it takes. If you want it, it is yours, one of the few things you can choose for yourself and that no one can take from you.

I am no Christian, but I wear the cross in a necklace every day over my heart. Jesus was the most spiritual person I know of in all of human history. He inspires me every time I touch the cross to do good. That is what spirituality means to me.

St. Thomas said in the Bible that a man is good when his will takes joy in what is good, evil when his will takes delight in what is wrong. I am virtuous when I find happiness in a moral life, writes Thomas,  sinful when I take pleasure in a sinful life.

Other people are always trying to define me, but they can’t: the things that I love tell us all who I am.

A temperamental man or woman may be more inclined to anger than another.

But as long as he remains sane, they are still free not to be angry.

Anger, at times, can be turned either to good or evil, depending on our wishes.

If I desire evil, my temper could become a weapon of evil, even against my own soul. If I desire what is good, my temper can become a controlled instrument to help other people overcome the obstacles they face in the world.

And above all, I’ve learned this about my search for the spiritual life: I must worship the truth and face it: first about me, and then about the world beyond me because I can’t do one without the other.

“There is no greater disaster in the spiritual life,” wrote Merton, “than to be immersed in unreality, for life is maintained and nourished in us by our strong relations with realities outside and above us. When our life feeds on unreality, it must starve. It must therefore die.”

9 Comments

  1. Another very powerful and meaningful post, Jon. i’ve read it 3 times….and will re-read. So much to ponder and reflect on here……… thank you
    Susan M

  2. it is good to have kindred spiritss on this journey even as we try to bring a loving presence into the situations where peaple are driven and angry.

  3. “All temperaments can serve as the material for ruin or salvation.” I loved this from Merton, Jon. Years ago, I cut an abusive sister out of my life, and now and then still feel like I should be a “more spiritual person” or I feel like ” a truly spiritual person would just take the high road” and let her back into my life, and love her because after all, she’s sick. My son told me, “Mom, you can still love her the best way for YOU, and just because that can’t safely be face to face, doesn’t mean you’re the bad person here.” I think I suffer a bit, still, from my old paradigm of what spiritual means, (long suffering) and I am adjusting it all the time. I am glad to read about your journey!

  4. Jon,
    Thank you for this fine writing. One of the reasons I like to follow you, is that you don’t just post random and first thoughts that come to your mind about a subject, but it is evident that you do research, read, and quote other spiritual sources in this case. To me, it offers some level of validity and justification for your viewpoint of the article.

    To me, I always held the belief that the reason we were here was because we were all in this together and helping each other produced a greater community, nation or whatever. While my ego drives the notion of greed and securing money for oneself, I make sure I help somebody everyday of my life. I know how things work in this world, to steal your idea you use of people who have some mechanical aptitude. Everyday, I call people in my age group (late 60’s) and offer any help I can provide from mowing the lawn to rewiring outlets to fixing lamps to repairing a broken chair. I am no Saint. There are many people who think I am evil because I have a brain that can release anger very easily. Especially, when I see greed being sewn on the poor and marginalized humanity. I literally cant stand people that knowingly take advantage of other people.

    So I fight the demon everyday of controlling my anger against what I perceive to be injustices. I will admit that I have used that anger knowingly to provide energy and impetus to fight for causes that I believe in. Many counselors, people of religious faith and ex-wife consider me a bad person because I use that anger , not to hurt people, but will argue, explain, call authorities and push people to treat their fellow man with more respect and willingness to help.
    They say, that is the reason I’m broke and alone in my late 60’s. I should have spent that energy trying to horde money look for ways to produce more income at any cost, because, they say, that is why they are better than me because they have obtained more money from society than I have.

    They believe, God is punishing me for putting others first, instead of going out and making more money. Sometimes the anger wins of my personality and hopefully compassion side of my mental makeup wins too.

  5. Said well, thanks. “There is no greater disaster in the spiritual life,” wrote Merton, than to be immersed in unreality”. I think Merton’s comment are the words of a true seeker.

  6. Jon, this is a powerful message and I think the comments reflect this. I to have used my anger to fight for causes I believe in. If you care enough about an issue you will fight for justice. Because of health reasons, I’ve cut some close relatives and a friend out of my life too. It was a matter of surviving or not. I’m sure they see it differently. Sometimes my anger gets the best of me. I was really taken by Ed’s comment. As an older person, I wish there was an Ed in my neighborhood. I feel invisible and sometimes I could use a helping hand. Financial success is not what makes one successful. According to that thinking, Trump is a success. There’s the biggest example of a hypocrite I’ve ever seen. Carries a Bible but probably has never read a word of it. Calls people to Washington and gets a supporter killed and makes no move to stop the violence. A successful person contributes to society not only monetarily but with their time, and they don’t turn a blind eye to the injustice in the world. They may appear angry but it’s because they care so deeply. I hope I said that right.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Email SignupFree Email Signup