24 March

My Neighbor Moses, A New Friend, An Amish Friend

by Jon Katz

I met an Amish miller and farmer today, he is a neighbor, and unless I misread our time together, he is now a friend as well. His name is Moses, and he lives right up the road from our farm.

He took time out from plowing his field to come and talk to me about his work, his life, and the help he might need.

I pulled into his driveway, and I was fascinated to see him plowing his fields behind three huge draft horses. His command of the horses was astonishing, unlike anything I’ve ever seen before.

He spoke to them almost in a whisper; they pulled his plow on a hill so steep on one side I was sure the horses would fall right over on me. He guided them calmly and skillfully, and mostly, in whispers.

I had come to bring books to his children, avid readers.

He wanted to thank me for that. I asked him how I might help him, and he said the only thing he needed once in a while was help in driving or picking up friends and family who come to visit and ride the bus or take the train.

I explained my life as a writer and Maria’s work as an artist. He said he would like to see her studio. He asked me if I write all the time.

He asked if I could go to the Albany Train station early Thursday to pick up visiting friends. I said I couldn’t go tomorrow; I’m getting my final Covid-19 vaccine.  But I would be happy to help when I could, and so would my wife.

Moses said several Amish friends and family were moving to the area.

He told me he had come in the winter and had not yet built the house; he and his family lived in a temporary storage building.

His farm has 100 acres; he has so many plans for it.

He was plowing, he said, to plant vegetables; he would build a vegetable stand in front of the house for the summer.

I could hardly believe he was going to plow that huge field by himself, the horses pulling him gently and quietly, responding instantly to commands so soft I could not hear them, even 10 feet away.

All three horses moved in complete unison.

I held my breath as the horses navigated steep hillside turns and were stopped by rocks. Moses was able to give commands to each individual horse at the same time, so the horse on the side of the steep hill stepped more cautiously, and the other two picked up the stack.

It was like a choreographed ballet.

Moses asked me what I did and what Maria did and said he would love to come and see the donkeys; he was thinking of getting some as guard animals.

It was interesting, America is so polarized, I am always cautious about talking to people too openly. There was no caution talking with Moses, as different as we are from one another.

He also hoped to have goats and sheep and wanted to talk about our sheep. I felt a curious connection with this man; he was open, soft-spoken, and gentle. I winced when I saw his plow hit a rock or piece of slate and twist and almost knock him over. He would stand up, bend over, dig out the rock with his hands and pick it up.

He plans to re-arrange the hill and the approaches to it.

I asked him if I could stand and watch him with the horses for a while, and he said certainly, that would be fine. I just stood back and watched for a while. I could have watched all day.

Time after time, he got out and pulled the rock out himself, tossing it down the hill. When I drove by later, about ten rows of soil was ready for planting.

He said his two sons – the ones I got the Hardy Boy books for – are eager to work with the horses and learn how to train them. I see I am a piker when it comes to animal training.

It seems to me the Amish are master breeders and trainers. There is no emotion shown to the horses; they are work tools, not family members.

They don’t seem to mind.

We talked for nearly an hour, and I was sorry to leave. I had to go somewhere else. “Come back,” he said, “we can sit down and talk with each other.” I’m game.

I urged him to come to visit us; he said he would.

I asked him – I always ask an Amish person  – or anyone – if it’s okay to take a picture. The Amish believe it’s sacrilegious to have their facial images captured.  I am careful not to do that, although a number of journalists and photographers have been given permission to photograph Amish families. Maybe one day.

I asked if I could take photos of his horses and sometimes, of him, if  I didn’t show his face. Yes, he said, that would be fine.

I liked this man and felt at ease with him. We hardly know one another, but it felt as if I were talking to a trusted friend.

He seemed very comfortable within himself. He was thin and bearded, but he could toss huge rocks as if they were tennis balls. I told him I was 73, and he told me he was just over 50.

Like most Amish men, he was missing some teeth. The Amish don’t believe in paying for dentistry.

His connection to the horses fascinated me; I get so many e-mails from people claiming that the Amish abuse their horses, but I hope he will one day permit me to take a video of his work with the horses. I’d have to do it in a way that didn’t reveal his face.

I think any animal lover would be mesmerized. It is a wonder what animals and people can do when they work together.

I appreciate having Moses in my life.

He will be a good neighbor to us, and I hope to return the favor. I’m thrilled by the book project; these kids love to read, their parents are delighted they have books to read.

12 Comments

  1. Love these posts. We have the opportunity to expand cultural knowledge in so many surprising places, dont we?
    Curious as to your community’s response overall, especially regarding the availability of land.

  2. I am so fascinated by the Amish and now your relationship with these families will be wonderful and enriching to follow. Thank you for being open to all these different experiences and then sharing them with us. It really is a precious gift.

  3. What an awesome story, Jon! I’m so glad you met Moses and found a new good friend. I would love to have some Amish friends. There is a Mennonite settlement about 40 miles south of us, and we used to go down to their restaurant all along to eat. They are wonderful cooks and sweet people. They seem a little more modern than the Amish and do use cars.

  4. Don’t believe the naysayers about how the Amish treat their horses. Most of them have names and will respond to their owners when working. You are so fortunate to have them as neighbors, Jon

  5. Love this story, and love that you have these new relationships – for you and Maria, and then for us to vicariously enjoy! You’re helping us all dispel many cultural stereotypes.

  6. Imagine the patience it takes to teach those horses how to respond to his verbal instructions. They may not be treated as pets, but they are treated well, just like the farmer takes care of his tractor, the Amish take care of their animals. I am enjoying these small insights into their life. Thank you.

    1. You can’t get an animal to do those things out of fear, only out of trust and clarity. The horses are very content, they are lucky, they have work, good food, exercise, and training. Like the carriage horses in New York, they are among the luckiest horses in the world.

  7. I really look forward to your blog Jon, I like the Amish too I lived in the country for 12 years and they are fine people to deal with. I was also around draft horses and owned several other types myself. The draft horses were so gentle, feels quite spiritual to be with them, for me any horses actually.

  8. My sister owned a farm. And they had Amish in the area. She told me that if you get an Amish trained horse you’ll get a good horse. The horses in all your photos look well feed. My sister had a horse that was scary. Truthfully, I would have put it down. An animal that size has to be under control. The Amish near me have changed over the years. At one Amish furniture store I see they are now using computers and cellphones. They had installed solar panels on the roof. But I think they still hire someone to deliver their furniture.

  9. I love reading about your Amish neighbors and seeing their horses. I wonder if the girls would like to read the Nancy Drew books. When I was a kid I would read my sister’s Cherry Ames and Annette books. Of course I loved my Little House on the Prairie collection. I know that many Amish are horrible to their animals (and their wives and kids too) but so are many “English”. There is good and bad in every group.

  10. What a delight! I would love to be a part of your future visits and enjoy the conversation. Rather than being “a fly on the wall”, I’d be a fly on one of the horses. I’m looking forward to more accounts of your bonding with the neighbors.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Email SignupFree Email Signup