18 June

A Broken Band Of Brothers

by Jon Katz

Oh, brothers! I don’t care for brothers. My elder brother won’t die, and my younger brothers never seem to do anything else…” – Oscar Wilde, the Picture of Dorian Gray.

In our country, it seems to me that the sanctity of family – parents, brothers, sisters, children, aunts and uncles –  has been elevated almost to a cult status, a national myth.

Family comes first, it is above all else, one can never escape family or get away from it, or its obligations. The language of family in books, movies, on TV reminds me of the way North Koreans talk about their Supreme and Eternal leaders.

Family is everything, and can never be denied. The faith of the Sopranos is our faith. Movies rarely end with anybody walking away from family, no matter how fraught or poisonous.

Every movie, song or story about families ends the same way.

That, as is perhaps obvious, was not my story. And my story is not over yet, not when it comes to family and brothers.

My brother is 12 years older than I am, he left our house when my sister and I were very young. He  was lucky to escape, and he never looked back. I didn’t see him much at all for 20 years or so, and I was long gone by then.

Fairly or not, I always felt he abandoned my sister and I, he ran away from us, we were never welcome in his new home, nor did he ever come to see how we were. I read all those stories about brothers rushing to help one another, it was just a fable to me.

My brother never wanted to know, he had his own life, his own family.

That was his right of course, but it widened the already wide and growing gap between us. Once, my sister and I ran away to his house – we were always running away – and we stood outside for the longest time knocking on his door. But nobody answered.

The thing is, I barely knew my brother, it wasn’t like in the movies or on TV. He barely knew me, we never saw one another. He took me horseback riding once when I was very young.

From time to time, we might see one another at family dinners, or while visiting my parents, and we always said we should get together, but we never did.

We had absolutely nothing in common, and neither one of us ever quite got the other.

He married several times, had several children, several different careers. He had a radio show, and when a book of mine came out, he would always book me on the show, and seemed proud of me, but otherwise, we never spoke. People who heard us thought we were best buddies.

We connected when he got divorced and was frightened, and he called me and I helped him, I gave him some money. I didn’t see him for many years after that, he came to Maria and my wedding.

Then it was my turn to get divorced, and I needed help and he helped me, he sent me money to help us move into our current home, I was broke and needed help. I was so grateful not only for the money, but to have a brother at last. We will stand together, he told me, we will get through this.

We didn’t stand together through my troubles. My brother stopped speaking to me for several years. I think he was worried I would ask for more money.  The one time we each seemed to be brothers to one another yielded nothing but more hurt and suspicion and more distance.

He had a very different story to tell about our family than I did, and he didn’t want to hear mine. His story made me crazy. Perhaps each of our stories was true, at least to us.

He was passing through the area four or five years ago, and Maria and I met him and his wife for dinner.

My brother began talking about my mother and father at this dinner, and I got nauseous and got sick and had to stay in the bathroom for much of the meal. In the car, I felt better and I told Maria I couldn’t imagine what had happened, I got sick even before the food had come.

She looked at  me incredulously and said, don’t you know? It was talking to your brother. There was just too much for us to overcome.

When I had my open heart surgery, my  brother was the only person I knew in the world who never called or visited me. Later on, he said he didn’t  have my number and  besides, he said he followed my progress on Facebook and the blog. I understand why he didn’t call, I think it was just too difficult for him.

I had begun to embrace radical acceptance, and rather than be judging him I decided to let him go, and with him the idea of having a brother. He owed me nothing.  I had no right to judge him.

I have made my own family now, and it is a loving and caring one, I could never go back. My brother and I have danced this  dance again and again in my life, and we just kept swirling around.  I can’t dance anymore. Reality is everything to me.

My brother started messaging me recently, he says he wants me in his life, but I don’t wish to be in his life. He was upset with me.

He would only talk about this in a text message, a form I hate for having important conversations. The messages got heated, there was a lot of feeling in them, and I blurted out what had happened to me. Now do you understand?

But he didn’t, saying only that perhaps one day we could talk about it.

I realized he has become the kind of connection I have been writing about, someone who only knows me by my books or blog or Facebook posts from the blog. He called me his wonderful talented baby brother who he has always loved deeply but who has not wanted a relationship with him and he said he didn’t know why.

I understand now that he will never know why. And I am done with trying to tell him, it’s really not my place.

No more dancing. The Dalai Llama says what really matters is how well you learn to let go.

And what also matters is that I need to take care of myself, I need to protect myself. My brother is not good for me, and that means almost certainly that I am not good for him.

I think my brother is angry with me once more, it was clear from his messages, and disappointed when I told him I can’t be in his life. I respect the power and meaning of family, but I also respect the different reality that exists for so many people – me, Maria, others that we know.

I don’t know what my brother believes, I don’t know him any better than he knows me. As I write this, I feel the old anger and resentment swell up in me, and even in my writing, and that is not who I wish to be or how I want to write. I will do both of us the favor of staying out of his life.

I don’t hold all of the truth and wisdom in my pocket.

But I believe getting away from my family saved my life and even exchanging messages with him is very painful for me. I was up all night re-living it all, stomach churching, sweating and shaking.

My brother and I are not a part of the band of brothers. Myths are not always true, not always something to live by.

16 Comments

  1. There are toxic people in the world. There are narcissistic people in the world. There are people who lack compassion. They are somebody’s brother, sister, mother father.

  2. Very very deep. Very very much a life I can relate to. When you have not taken care of yourself, (I am referring to my own life) you find it hard to do or release the things that hurt you. I thank you for your openess. I appreciate your truth so much… may you feel peace…. thanks Jon

  3. Yes, family. The memories sustain me, the early ones. Death came too soon, nobody could handle it. Our family broke apart. In the end, after 30 years of living next door to my dad. Enjoying him in small amounts of course, he got ready to die. My dad had welcomed me home with an eighteen month old son, two German shepherds and my cat. My dad let me have my old room back, the whole old big family home, actually. I rebuilt my life. Over 30 years my dad helped be a father to all 3 of my kids. Their dad was always absent. I cooked a lot of great meals, shared every holiday. When he became closer to death, two of my sisters who had been gone for decades, returned. One convinced him to change his will, ( “You’re the executor of my estate, dear”)… they locked us out, Barricaded our family home backdoor. I told my youngest son, leave them. They wanted a battle, My father would not have liked that. I yelled in through the little crack “ Love you dad”. After all the cruelty and destruction, they left for their side of the country. Their loss, to not have us . I have no intentions of ever seeing or speaking to them again, not because I’m don’t like them, but because I love me and my family, my three kids. The eldest sister who masterminded the whole thing is a millionaire who made missiles for a living. Destroyed every man she met, many, all. Destroyed all life. Never owned a pet and resented mine. I call her the empress of death, and when I pray at night, I say, and mean, thank you god that I am not her. Family.

  4. So sad to read this & understand how very, very painful your childhood was and all the ongong losses.

  5. Thanks for writing about your experience with your brother Jon.
    All of us who have difficult relationships with family have to make these tough decisions. I have, many others. ..Taking care of ourselves in that way is the best way to be a happy, healthy person – then we can share our gifts with others. Once you really let go of those toxic relationships life gets so much more enjoyable. As you said, Family is not always blood it’s with whom you make it!

    1. Thanks Anne, I keep thinking the same thing..I have to take care of myself, so that I can take care of the people I love..

      1. Dori, thanks but I don’t see my life as sad at all, I am very lucky and grateful every day…every body has battles to fight…

  6. Jon, your writing on your brother was heartfelt and reflected what is happening in today’s society in regard to families, some families…it is called estrangement. It is generally an issue between a grown child and a parent, the mother mostly is targeted. There is a breakdown in family life if you care to read about estrangement and the books now written on toxic parents, toxic, narcissistic mothers and why estranging from a parent is the only way to save yourself. Your anger isn’t I think as much towards your brother as the circumstances that you found yourself in as a child and the fact that he isn’t able to hear you on this, isn’t appearing able to hear you on other issues. Families are complicated relationships, but you’ve written well and honestly. As usual,
    Sincerely,
    Sandy Proudfoot

    1. Thanks Sandy, for that thoughtful and interesting diagnosis, I read it carefully. I have to say I don’t think that’s quite what’s going on with me, as a number of therapists and I have sorted out for more than 30 years. I certainly have had anger at my parents, but my feelings about my brother are very real and long-standing and in many ways, quite separate. I think your observation about my being angry at the circumstances my sister and I found ourselves in is quite true. It is very hard to separate the anger in me from the many present possibilities.

  7. I often fall back on the phrase, an accident of birth, when dealing with family. It covers most situations quite well. Having said that, messing with my little sister will get you all kinds of unwanted attention from me. It’s a big brother thing. One can only be what he or she is at the time.

  8. In my 60s I finally understand why one of my brothers just never treated me well. He never wanted me born! He was the second son and worshipped his older brother. I come along (a whoopsie), the girl and turn him into a middle child. Add a big dose of karma and voila, a tragic sibling relationship.

    They come in all shapes and sizes and they can a lot of suffering. If all you ever wanted was your sibling to love you and they never do, it is hard on a nascent soul.

    The best and ideal idea of family is wonderful, for those who don’t get that, it is a lifetime of messages about how we didn’t get “there”.

  9. wow, this totally sums up me sister and I, a lesson I will take to heart, the grief of loosing the idea of having a caring sister has been weighing on me for a long time. time to let it go. Thanks Jon

  10. I have a sister who is bipolar and very toxic to be around. My mother coined the phrase emotional vampire and she was right on the mark. I was 55 when my father died. She turned it into an opportunity to call and message me crying hysterically Everytime. Finally, I had to pull back and tell her to call if we could have a conversation not fraught with hysteria. She texts now and then but 5 years later, I have never had that phone call and I am okay with that. Family is difficult. Do what keeps you same is what I say.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Email SignupFree Email Signup