19 February

Am I A Writer Or A Story Teller? Or Both? (Photo For Sale)

by Jon Katz

(This Photo, “Storyteller” Is For Sale. $125. Fine Art Print, Hahnemuhle Photo Rag 100 per cent cotton acid free paper, archival ink, signed, unframed. On Maria’s Etsy Shop Wednesday, or e-mail: [email protected])

If you have had your identity taken from you, then identity matters.  It will always matter.

Identity is something I think about all of the time. One of the reasons I have fought back so hard against people who refuse to let me make my own decisions and  mistakes or who try to tell me what to write is my sensitivity about identity.

I’ve never been able to properly explain my need to make my own decisions, and find my own way. It is because I lost my way and could not make good decisions for so many years. We crazy people are often lucky, we get to recover every day, I am getting stronger all the time.

How does one grow in confidence and reasoning when thousands of people are telling him or her what to do? Thoreau would have hung himself in Walden Pond.

I see this presumption as taking my identity away, blocking off my own search to  be a fully realized human being who can make my own decisions. And yes, I know they are well-meaning. And no, I can’t say that really matters.The road to hell…..

I’ve  written 25 (soon 26 ) books and I never stop thinking about identity or writing about it.

I have always identified myself as a writer, or an author. Proud words for me. And I doubt I will ever be desensitized to the meaning of Identity, it is literally who I am. No one can take it from me.

I also have come to realize that I am a story-teller, deep down in my DNA, story telling is a huge part of me. The literati sniff at story telling, they think of it as a kind of carnival work. They say you can’t be both a writer and a story-teller, that the two things are very different.

I don’t think so.  I have never been loved by the literati, thank God I don’t have to deal with that. They don’t get to decide who I am either, that is for me to do.

A writer by dictionary definition is a person who uses written words in various styles and techniques to communicate ideas.  A story-teller is something quite different: he or she is defined as someone who conveys events in words, images or sounds.

Wikipedia says story telling describes the social and cultural activity of sharing stories, often with improvisation, theatrics, or embellishment. Crucial elements of story telling include plot, characters and narrative point of view.

Merriam-Webster defines writing as the act or process of one who writes, such as the act or art of forming visible letters and characters; letters or characters that serve as visible signs of ideas, words or symbols.

It is, in fact, possible to be a writer and a story-teller.

I know, because I am both. Many of the pieces I wrote on my blog are stories – of my life, Maria, donkeys, dogs and the people I meet, and the struggles I  face. I do use improvisation and minimal but occasional embellishment. I took a creative writing course with the famed John Updike, he said the writer’s job is to embellish stories a bit when necessary, never let a bad or dull story stand if you can brush it up a bit.

I also use my photography, videos and voice software  to tell stories, and that is important, because one cliche is very true: photographs can’t lie, not even in the age of Photoshop (which I have never used.)

The writer and story-teller have powerful new tools to shape their work, and the old lines and boundaries have been pretty much obliterated.

My photos give authenticity to my words and stories, I make sure that people can see for themselves almost everything that I write about. I believe that has been  essential to my blog’s success. Over the years, my pictures have become as important as my words. Some of them are even beginning to sell.

I also believe in Tom Wolfe’s idea about truth.

Truth isn’t always completely literal, you must be honest and authentic in the aggregate, you must not be  self-serving or dishonest, you must accept and acknowledge the worst parts of yourself. You can also be creative and inventive in work and stories.

My blog is a story teller’s blog as well as a writer’s blog.

I use writing to talk about ideas and the important passages of my life.

I use story telling to describe my life on Bedlam Farm with Maria and the animals. I might touch up a tale once in a while, but I never lie, at least knowingly. And I believe salvation comes from never lying to yourself.

The person you read here and in my books (hopefully) is the real me, when people meet me, they are not surprised. They know what to expect, and for me, that is the highest compliment a writer or story-teller can receive.

5 Comments

  1. Having recently been at the Art Institute in Chicago, my friend and I have been discussing Seurat’s A Sunday Afternoon On The Island Of La Grande Jatte. As always, it seems amazing that someone could paint something so immense and wonderful.
    Today, in thinking about your blog I have come to compare someone’s memoir to that great panting. “What am amazing and challenging life” I would say about that person. “How did he or she manage it”.? Reading the memoir is like gazing at that painting. Reading your blog is like sitting with the artist every day as he creates it, every joy, every frustration, every cramp in their hand and neck and back, every moment when you work up close and every time you step back and look at the big picture. It is being a part of someone’ amazing and courageous life.

    1. Penny, that is a striking and beautiful message for me to get, and I thank you for it. It means a lot to me, and I am humbled by it. I can’t help wonder if that interesting person could really be me, but I thank you for suggesting it..

  2. I don’t comment often, but feel compelled to this time. This is my mantra: “We create our own lives and we can’t create anyone else’s for them” nor is it appropriate. And, it seems like a boundary issue to me for other people to tell me how to live my life. I fully support you, Jon, in creating yours in whatever way you choose.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Email SignupFree Email Signup